Witicles Experts Online Articles Directory
     
Witicles Experts Articles Directory Witicles Experts Articles DirectoryWiticles Experts Articles DirectoryWiticles Experts Articles Directory

Welcome, Guest!     Sign Up    Sign In
Sponsored Ads

Create Free Website or Blog with Hubpile

Negotiate To Succeed






Author Box


Abiola Benjamin ObayomiAbiola Benjamin Obayomi
Real Estate is my Profession. The change we need in Nigeria begins with all of us doing things differently. Collectively, we can make Nigeria work.
Joined 3 years ago
From Ile-Ife, Osun State
Total Articles 213

Recent Articles From Author

# BREAK FREE FROM EVERY DOUBTS AND SELF-LIMITING BELIEFS
# JUST A LITTLE PUSH
# THE FAMILY SIDE OF GOD
# LORD, TEACH US TO PRAY (Luke 11:1-4)

Namecheap.com Namecheap.com



Become A Witicles.Com Expert Contributor Today



Shop for Books online in Nigeria at kpiBooks.com.ng Order your favourite books online now, Save the stress & Pay online or with cash at Your Doorstep!


We help our esteemed clients develop web strategy that works!
Call us @ +234 803 578 3880




Authors Spotlight
Gboyega Adedeji  Gboyega Adedeji
Gboyega Adedeji is a Veteran Writer on Witicles.comVeteran Author
238 Articles
   I am a Nigerian and an Ambassador of Christ sent to Nigeria for the cause of His Kingdom. By divine-making, I read, teach and ... from Abuja, Nigeria


Free Online Articles Editor  Free Online Articles Editor
Free Online Articles Editor is a Veteran Writer on Witicles.comVeteran Author
137 Articles
   We challenge the minds of people towards mental and attitudinal shift and National transformation. We are the Editorial team of Witicles.... from Abuja, Nigeria


Abiola Benjamin Obayomi  Abiola Benjamin Obayomi
Abiola Benjamin Obayomi is a Veteran Writer on Witicles.comVeteran Author
213 Articles
   Real Estate is my Profession. The change we need in Nigeria begins with all of us doing things differently. Collectively, we can make Nigeri... from Ile-Ife, Osun State


Omolara Adedeji  Omolara Adedeji
Omolara Adedeji is a Veteran Writer on Witicles.comVeteran Author
60 Articles
   I am a kingdom expander and I believe in the testimony of a transformed life as the greatest testimony of all. I am a voice of God for m... from Abuja, Nigeria



Sell Your Books online in Nigeria, Earn 80% from book sales


Top Articles
CONSAT: Nigeria DTH Cable Television That Challenges DsTV, MyTV, Startimes and Others
Top 10 Reasons for Nigeria's Undeveloped Economy
INSIGHTS On Tithes & Offerings from Brother Gbile Akanni
The Pyramid of Friendship: Secret of Effective Relationships
The Quick Fix for Nigeria's Underdevelopment and Unemployment


Recent Articles
BREAK FREE FROM EVERY DOUBTS AND SELF-LIMITING BELIEFS
JUST A LITTLE PUSH
THE FAMILY SIDE OF GOD
LORD, TEACH US TO PRAY (Luke 11:1-4)
The Good That Religion Can Do By Feyi Fawehinmi


Recent Comments
Krupa Mehta
Trending Indian Georgette Saree, Silk Sari and Pure Chiffon Sarees
1 week ago Nice!

Mahipalpur Escort
CONSAT: Nigeria DTH Cable Television That Challenges DsTV, MyTV, Startimes and Others
4 weeks ago Nice post, its very interesting to read something good like this, hope you will continue sharing your thoughts with us. http://www.escort-gurgaon.com/mahipalpur-escort.html Mahipalpur Escort

Mahipalpur Girls
CONSAT: Nigeria DTH Cable Television That Challenges DsTV, MyTV, Startimes and Others
4 weeks ago This post is very good for us. It has got a lot of benefit from us.I hope that you will be writing this post again http://www.russiongirlsinmahipalpur.in Call Girl In Mahipalpur

Site Clouds
Witicles, Articles, Webnigerians,Experts, Submit Articles, Become A Writer, Writing, Technology, Leadership, God, Government, Management, Nigeria, Society, Culture, Authentic Articles
Social Sharing



Sponsored Ads


Namecheap.com
Article Category >>>News and Society

Femi Falana: Why Government Loses Corruption Cases

By Abiola Benjamin Obayomi       Apr 13, 2017


Femi Falana: Why Government Loses Corruption Cases

Introduction: Following the loss of corruption cases last week many Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) agree with the Federal Government that corruption is fighting back. However, before pointing accusing fingers at the judiciary it is pertinent to examine the facts and circumstances of the loss of such cases. In sharing my findings with the representatives of the CSOs gathered here I shall predict that the government stands to lose more corruption cases unless the federal government is prepared to reorganize the anti-graft agencies and review the anti-corruption policy in line with the proposals designed by the Presidential Advisory Committee Against Corruption.

Concern over loss of prosecution cases

Following a string of court rulings against high-profile corruption cases last week, CSOs have expressed the view that corruption is fighting back. On its own part, the Socio-Economic Rights & Accountability Project (SERAP) has called on President Buhari to “adopt a revolutionary approach to his government’s fight against corruption by referring high-level official corruption cases to the International Criminal Court for investigation and possible prosecution”. It may interest SERAP to know that I actually submitted a petition to the office of the Special Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court in October 2015 on the same subject matter. My petition had alleged the commission of a crime against humanity by military officers and other police officers who engaged in the criminal diversion of $15 billion earmarked for the procurement of arms and ammunition which led to the brutal killing of over 25,000 people and the displacement of two million people by the Boko Haram sect.

Former President has also expressed concern over the loss of corruption cases by the Federal government. While blaming the development on lack of proper investigation and poor prosecution Chief Obasanjo has asked the government to rely on “ ogbologbo lawyers” and stop the practice of farming out corruption cases to external lawyers. With profound respect, the “ogbologbo lawyers” that President Obasanjo has in mind are no longer easy to come by Hence, under the Obasanjo administration both the ICPC and EFCC led by the Honourable Justice Mustapha Akanbi (rtd) and Mallam Nuhu Ribadu respectively engaged the services of external lawyers in the prosecution of many high profile cases. In fact, Mr. Rotimi Jacobs SAN who has successfully prosecuted more corruption cases than any lawyer in Nigeria is an external lawyer.

Having reviewed the circumstances under which the corruption cases were lost by the federal government I can say, without any fear of contradiction, that there is no basis for blaming the judiciary. It is also not a case of corruption fighting back. As far as I am concerned the cases were lost due to official negligence and lack of interagency cooperation by the federal ministry of justice, the anti-graft agencies and the State Security Service. In order to appreciate the basis of my conclusion, it is pertinent to review the facts of the cases which were lost last week.

FRN v MIKE OZEKHOME

In the course of investigating the criminal diversion of the sum of $2.1 billion from the office of NSA the EFCC claimed that it had traced N2.3 billion to Mr. Ayo Fayose, the governor of Ekiti state. On the basis of the finding, the EFCC applied for and obtained an order ex parte from Idris J. of the Lagos judicial division of the federal high court to freeze the accounts of Mr. Fayose’s account at the Zenith Bank. But the application to vacate the order filed before the Ado Ekiti judicial division of the court was granted by Taiwo J. The EFCC promptly appealed against the order.

However, further investigation revealed that N75 million was paid as a legal fee to Mr. Mike Ozekhome, the counsel to Mr. Fayose. At that juncture, the EFCC applied for and obtained an order ex parte to freeze Chief Ozekhome’s account from Anka J. of the Federal High Court sitting in Lagos. The senior counsel applied to set aside the order. In setting aside the ex parte and unfreezing Chief Ozekhome’s account Anka J. held that he could not sit as an appellate court over Taiwo J. who had order that Mr. Fayose’s account be unfrozen. The EFCC has filed an appeal against the order. All hope is not lost as the EFCC has appealed to the Court of Appeal to set aside the order of Taiwo which unfroze the account of Governor Ayo Fayose.

FRN V ORUBEBE

The Defendant was charged with criminal diversion of N1.9 billion from the money earmarked for the construction of the east-west road. The ICPC was prosecuting the case. But at the resumed hearing of the matter last week the Honourable Attorney-General of the Federation filed a nolle prosequi seeking to withdraw the case pursuant to his powers under section 174 of the Constitution. Consequently, the case was struck out while the defendants were discharged. Once the case was discontinued by the Prosecution based on the instruction of the Attorney-General the trial judge had no choice but to strike it out.

FRN v MRS. PATIENCE JONATHAN

The EFCC traced the sum of $5.9 million to the account of the respondent. Convinced that the fund was a proceed of crime the EFCC applied for an order freezing the account. The respondent filed an application to unfreeze the account. As no counter-affidavit was filed challenging the application it was granted by Olatoregun J. last week. Instead of pursuing an appeal the EFCC may wish to consider all available options in the circumstance. In particular, an application may be made before the same court praying that the order be set aside based on cogent reasons.

FRN v JUSTICE ADENIYI ADEMOLA & 2 ORS.

Following the raid on the homes of seven judges last year the defendants were arraigned in court on an 18-count charge. When the prosecution closed its case the defendants filed a no case submission. In a marathon ruling delivered last week the learned trial judge, Okeke J. upheld the no-case submission struck out the case and discharged the defendants. With respect, the learned trial judge ought not to have considered the merit of the case and the credibility of witnesses in the ruling. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case coupled with relevant decided authorities on no case submission I am of the strong view that the government has an arguable appeal.

I suggest that the appeal already filed against the ruling of the learned trial judge by the government should be pursued with vigor. My belief in the possibility of the success of the appeal is anchored on the cases of Olawale Ajiboye v The State (1995) 8 NWLR (PT 414) 408 wherein the Supreme Court had this to say:

“It must be recognized that at the stage of a no case submission, the trial of the case is not yet concluded. At that stage, therefore, the court should not concern itself with the credibility of witnesses or the weight of their evidence even if they are accomplices. The court should also at this stage be brief in its ruling at too much might be said which at the end of the case might falter the court’s discretion. The court should again at this stage make no observation on the facts. (See for example R. v. Ekanem (1950) 13 WACA 108, Chief Odofin Bello v. The State (1967) NMLR 1, R v. Coker & Ors. 20 NLR 62.”

Limited capacity of anti-graft agencies

On a dispassionate consideration of the aforementioned cases, it is my submission that the courts cannot be blamed for the official negligence as well as the lack of interagency collaboration and coordination of the investigation and prosecution of corruption cases by the federal government. On some occasions, the State Security Service has refused to produce accused persons in court without any reason whatsoever. The development has led to the unnecessary delay in the prosecution of very serious corruption cases. It is obvious that the federal government wants to eat omelet without breaking eggs. It won’t work. Was it not because the accused persons had put together teams of senior and experienced lawyers that the federal government decided to set up of a national prosecution agency? But as no fund was made available to the agency corruption cases have not been assigned to the members of the agency. With the virtual collapse of the agency, the anti-graft agencies have been left on their own.

No doubt, the lawyers of the anti-graft agencies are largely industrious and committed to the fight against corruption. With a few investigators and persecutors working under a hostile environment, the EFCC has almost performed miracles! In other words, the investigators and prosecutors are hampered by a lack of experience and exposure. They are also overstretched and overwhelmed. In spite of such shortcomings, the EFCC has secured not less than 200 convictions in the last one year. In fact, some of the convicts are politically exposed persons including an ex-MD of NIMASA, an ex-governor, former chairman of local government councils and fuel subsidy fraudsters. Funds and properties worth hundreds of millions of dollars and billions of Naira have been seized and forfeited to the federal government.

As I did advocate in another forum last year, the military officers who diverted billions of dollars and naira earmarked for procurement of arms and armament should be charged before courts martial “for the serious offences of aiding the enemy, mutiny by impeding or sabotaging the counter-insurgency operations and stealing of public funds in contravention of sections 45, 52 and 66 of the Armed Forces Act. The proposed trial before such military courts will meet the justice of the case and the expectations of the public. More so, that the Rules of Procedure applicable in courts-martial have no room for frivolous adjournments, motions for bail, interlocutory appeals and preliminary objections.” With the handling of cases of indicted military officers by experienced military police investigators and prosecutors before courts-martial, the lawyers serving in the anti-graft agencies will have more time to concentrate on other cases.

Illegal opposition to bail applications by anti-graft agencies

One of the reasons why I have never prosecuted for the anti-graft agencies is the lackadaisical attitude of the government to the prosecution of corruption cases. I also cannot support the media trial of criminal suspects and the official policy of opposing the bail applications of criminal suspects. In Ameh Ebute V State (1994) 8 NWLR (Pt 360) 66 it was held that a suspect himself to the Police voluntarily is entitled to bail. In Ibori v. FRN (2009) 3 NWLR (pt 1127) 96 the Court of Appeal held that a person accused of economic crime is entitled to bail. Both decisions are binding on our courts and all authorities and persons.

Yet, the anti-graft agencies send lawyers to court to waste precious time on opposing the bail applications of suspects who might even have been granted administrative bail by them. Why should a serious lawyer go to court to ask a judge to lock up a suspect who has been granted bail and has never interfered with the investigation or attempted to jump bail? Instead of saving time and resources by asking for hearing dates prosecution counsel prefer to file copious counter-affidavits and written addresses in opposition to bail applications of accused persons.

Since bail has become automatic in the country let anti-graft agencies stop opposing bail application filed by suspects unless there are genuine grounds for filing objections. Bail should not be opposed as an official policy of a government. The government should stop playing into the hands of some persons accused of criminal diversion of public funds by refusing to comply with the orders of courts admitting them to bail. For some inexplicable reasons, the government has refused to comply with the orders of the ECOWAS Court, the FCT High Court and the federal high court to the effect that former National Security Adviser, Col Sambo Dasuki (rtd) be admitted to bail. In a similar situation, the federal high court did not allow the government to arraign retired Commodore Umar Mohammed until the order admitting him to bail was complied with.

The Buhari administration has directed the anti-graft agencies to ensure that corruption cases are not lost again. It is doubtful if the federal government is aware of the limited capacity of the anti-graft agencies. For instance, the ICPC receives an average of 100 petitions daily. The EFCC receives many more petitions from members of the public. Yet, the current EFCC leadership inherited a staff strength of 2,173. Even with the plan to engage 750 more staff, the EFCC will still have less than 3000 staff. The implication is that with such a few investigators and prosecutors the success rate of the agency is bound to be extremely limited.

While the concern of President Buhari is appreciated it ought to be pointed out that without adequate funding of the anti-graft agencies and motivation of investigators and prosecutors many more corruption cases are going to be lost to accused persons who have access to a well-prepared and well-paid team of lawyers. The British government spent millions of pounds on the investigation and prosecution of a former governor in Nigeria. If the government is genuinely desirous to win corruption cases it should be prepared to invest in the anti-graft agencies. The British government was reported to have spent about £20 million pounds on the investigation and prosecution of a former governor in Nigeria. As a matter of urgency, the government should immediately set aside part of the recovered loot to fund the investigation and prosecution of corruption cases.



From Witicles.Com: Thank you for the gift of your time. We appreciate you for reading this article published by Abiola Benjamin Obayomi. Witicles.Com is indeed your partner for your growth, effectiveness and maturity.

538 Views


If you need to re-publish this ARTICLE, please cite this article - (http://witicles.com/femi-falana-why-government-loses-corruption-cases-24601.html) and the Writer (Abiola Benjamin Obayomi)

Do You Find This Article Helpful?


Article Tags: Femi Falana, EFCC, Judiciary, Witicles
Save the Stress, Shop for Books Online in Nigeria - kpiBooks.com.ng
Article Source
Abiola Benjamin ObayomiAbout Abiola Benjamin Obayomi
Abiola Benjamin Obayomi Abiola Benjamin ObayomiAbiola Benjamin ObayomiAbiola Benjamin ObayomiAbiola Benjamin Obayomi

  Real Estate is my Profession. The change we need in Nigeria begins with all of us doing things differently. Collectively, we can make Nigeria work.


Social Sharing

If You Enjoyed This Article; Then, Share It On Your Social Network





     Copy This Short Link To The Article: http://i.witicles.com/kZ26c Femi Falana: Why Government Loses Corruption Cases Femi Falana: Why Government Loses Corruption Cases Femi Falana: Why Government Loses Corruption Cases Femi Falana: Why Government Loses Corruption Cases



Post Comment


Article Comments

No comment found! Be the first to share your thoughts on this article!



Namecheap.com
Related Articles




Author's Articles

" " " "




Related Books

Championship Fathering: How to win at Being a Dad

Coach Mom: 7 Strategies for Organizing Your Family Into An All-Star Team

Living Rich for Less: Create the Lifestyle You Want by Giving, Saving, and Spending Smart

Raising Agents of Transformation: Discipleship, Disciples & Disciples-Making







Home | Advertise With Us | About Us | Contact Us | How To Submit Articles | Article Writing Tips | Webnigerians.com | kpiBooks.Com | Our Sitemap: XML HTML

Copyright © 2013-2017 Witicles. All rights reserved.